Women’s March

qc6vnbe4jqs-jerry-kiesewetterI thought about entitling this “Why I Didn’t March” to practice my clickbaiting skills.

I didn’t march because I forgot it was happening. And I didn’t say anything about it because when it did happen, it was by turns so embarrassing and empowering and confusing and controversial and awesome that I didn’t want to touch it with a ten-foot pole.

I have three thoughts:

(1) Some of the signs, attire, attitudes, and rhetoric made me think of an Onion article called “Gay-Pride Parade Sets Mainstream Acceptance of Gays Back 50 Years”:

“I’d always thought gays were regular people, just like you and me, and that the stereotype of homosexuals as hedonistic, sex-crazed deviants was just a destructive myth,” said mother of four Hannah Jarrett, 41, mortified at the sight of 17 tanned and oiled boys cavorting in jock straps to a throbbing techno beat on a float shaped like an enormous phallus. “Boy, oh, boy, was I wrong.”

I feel the same way with the feminist movement, sometimes. I try so hard to convince my friends, family, and acquaintances that feminists are just normal people with normal concerns about legitimate issues, and then women wear vaginas around their heads, march naked, and scream about nasty women.*

Of course those are the only incidents of the march that the anti-feminists will see.

Sometimes feminists complain about how anti-feminists view them as angry, loud, obnoxious women with no moral compass, and I just glare at vagina-head.

* I get that the nasty women and pussy power rhetoric was ironic. Anti-feminists don’t.

(2) That said, it’s freaking awesome to me that something called the “Women’s March” spawned the largest U.S. protest, with zero arrests reported; it occurred on every continent; and it brought together a ton of different people. That massive accomplishment is associated primarily with women, the “weaker sex,” the ones “Biblically unfit for leadership.”

That’s a satisfying historical moment.

(3) Speaking of which, one of the most grating things about all the Christian anti-feminist responses is the ignorance about female oppression and sexism within Christianity itself. Someone wrote a many-times-shared “list” of all the freedoms women in America have compared to women elsewhere, implying that it’s ridiculous for American women to claim any sort of systemic oppression from patriarchy. (We’ve all seen similar posts.)

Personally, I have not experienced workplace discrimination. I have not experienced sexual harassment or assault. I am underpaid because I am a teacher, not a woman. I have, for the most part, encountered respectful men. I am not a person of color or an immigrant or a Muslim.

But I have experienced sexism and discrimination, and I experienced it all within Christianity.

Whenever I see this argument, that don’t see any real female oppression happening, I want to say this:

Open your eyes. Now look at your church. Now look at your beliefs. Now look at mainstream Christian culture. Now tell me, with a straight face, that there isn’t any real female oppression happening.

You won’t.

The worst part is that most won’t, because sexism within Christianity is so bad that it’s not even recognized as sexism. It’s Biblically sanctioned sexism.

Christians have told me and many other women, “You can’t do that because you’re a woman.”

That is straight-up sexism.

Our voices, our personalities, our gifts, our perspectives, and, in extreme but all-too-frequent cases, our lives have been repressed. That’s not even getting into the mess certain complementarian and patriarchal beliefs have made of people’s identities, marriages, and families.

Sure, women can pretty much “do as they please” in the secular world, give or take the challenges, but in mainstream Christianity, the majority still think that women are subordinate to men in some way, shape, or form. A vocal part of Christianity is even willing to risk Trinitarian heresy rather than revoke their views on women’s eternal subordination to man.

Even women support these things.

You know you’ve got a problem with patriarchy when it’s the women who argue most vehemently for the subordination of their fellow women.

I know, I really do know, that respectful, thoughtful men and women believe the Bible does not support women in leadership, whether in the home or in the church or in the secular world. I see how and why they came to those conclusions, and I see how and why they still hold to those conclusions (see first point, for example).

But it’s still sexism, no matter how you hermeneutically slice it.

Last Saturday, I hope there were feminists marching to protest Christian sexism, because that patriarchal beast is still alive and well.

Advertisements

8 thoughts on “Women’s March

  1. David

    Yes, but Bailey, you see, what you are missing here is that God’s sexist too. Otherwise why would He put all that stuff in the Bible?

    Now get back in the box. BACK INSIDE IT, I SAY.

    Like

      • DustinM-BC

        You have missed the mark. Equality- God created woman from the rib of Adam, as she is his help-meet, partner, equal=wife.
        I don’t know who your Pastor is or what denomination of “Christianity” you’re speaking, but I assure you that this is a monumental error.
        Ephesians speaks of marital roles. Women submit to their husbands and the husbands submit to God, as the spiritual head of the household. He is to love her as Christ Jesus loves His church (not a building). She cannot submit to a man (trust) unless her husband submits to God.
        Genesis declares the outline and definition of marriage per God. God is androgynous. Sexist? I think not. His design is complimentary and husband and wife are to work together, as the wife is a help-meet.
        What you are describing has nothing to do with what the Bible reads or what Jesus taught.
        You are referring to religious tyranny and was a reason God walked with us in Jesus. Do you know what religion means? It’s origin and why Jesus called religious people zealots?
        I only recommend that you read Proverbs 4:6-8 and go back to Genesis 2, Eph. 5 and then to Colossians, James, Titus and Galatians.
        Don’t be shy about asking questions for understanding and clarity. Hold your pastor responsible for teaching false doctrine (his/her interpretation) and make sure you have Scripture to support your questions.
        Thank you for sharing this post and opening comments.
        God bless you, always

        Side note: so you are aware, Christianity is NOT a religion (but it certainly has many denominations labeled by lost and manipulated men, which is dangerous), it’s an adjective used to describe those who follow Christ Jesus, a Jewish Rabbi, as were His disciples who spread the Gospel.

        Like

      • Bailey Steger

        Okay, one, this was a joke between David and me, and two, I don’t appreciate being lectured on my blog. Please refrain from doing so, and we’ll get along a-okay. ;) Check out my community rules for all future comments. Thanks!

        Like

  2. David

    Also, re: “You know you’ve got a problem with patriarchy when it’s the women who argue most vehemently for the subordination of their fellow women,” for whatever it’s worth, that’s /true/ but not unique to Christianity at /all/. Behold the same phenomenon in Orthodox Jews: http://www.tabletmag.com/jewish-life-and-religion/93971/tights-squeeze

    Really, if you read that article, a bunch of parallels will smack you in the face. The author’s like your sister from another mister. :)

    Like

  3. Donna

    I would just like to point out that if you are not a ‘person of color’ then you are probably dead. My color is olive. You probably have a color too. It is not white. White is the color of a sheet of paper. Just saying.

    Like

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s